Journal: The journal of physical chemistry. A

Article Title: Predicting the Strength of Anion-¹ Interactions of Substituted Benzenes: the Development of Anion-¹ Binding Substituent Constants.

PMID/MRN: 27779403

Publication Date: 2016-Nov-23

Abstract:

A computational study aimed at accurately predicting the strength of the anion-¹ binding of substituted benzenes is presented. The anion-¹ binding energies (E bind ) of 37 substituted benzenes and the parent benzene, with chloride or bromide were investigated at the MP2(full)/6-311++G** level of theory. In addition, energy decomposition analysis was performed on 27 selected chloride-arene complexes via symmetry adapted perturbation theory (SAPT), using the SAPT2+ approach. Initial efforts aimed to correlate the anion-¹ E bind values with the sum of the Hammett constants ? p (?? p ) or ? m (?? m ), as done by others. This proved a decent approach for predicting the binding strength of aromatics with electron-withdrawing substituents. For the Cl - -substituted benzene E bind values, the correlation with the ?? p and ?? m values of aromatics with electron-withdrawing groups had r 2 values of 0.89 and 0.87 respectively. For the Br - -substituted benzene E bind values, the correlation with the ?? p and ?? m values of aromatics with electron-withdrawing groups had r 2 values of 0.90 and 0.87. However, adding aromatics with electron-donating substituents to the investigation caused the correlation to deteriorate. For the Cl - -substituted benzene complexes the correlation between E bind values and the Hammett constants had r 2 = 0.81 for ?? p and r 2 = 0.84 for ?? m . For the Br - -substituted benzene complexes, the respective r 2 values were 0.71 for ?? p and 0.79 for ?? m . The deterioration in correlation upon consideration of substituted benzenes with electron-donating substituents is due to the anion-¹ binding energies becoming more attractive regardless of what type of substituent is added to the aromatic. A similar trend has been reported for parallel face-to-face substituted benzene-benzene binding. This is certainly counter to what electrostatic arguments would predict for trends in anion-¹ binding energies, and this discrepancy is further highlighted by the SAPT2+ calculated electrostatic component energies (E ele ). The E ele values for the Cl - -substituted benzene anion-¹ complexes are all more binding than the E ele value for the Cl - -benzene complex, with the exception of chloride-1,3,5-trimethylbenzene. Again, this is a similar trend to what has been reported for parallel face-to-face substituted benzene-benzene binding. A discussion on this surprising result is presented. In addition, an improved approach to predicting the relative anion-¹ binding strength of substituted benzene is developed using the results of the SAPT2+ calculations.